Who will play Redd?

[Loki]

I've gone around the site and listed the most popular names thrown in for playing Redd Heart. Which actress shall we choose? This poll is based on the most mentioned names and similarities to Redd in apperance and acting skills.

[Flitting_Shadow]

I can't picture Idina playing Redd; she's seems too nice despite her role in Wicked (which she doesn't seem evil in in the first place).
Whoever gets picked should be changed to look almost unrecognizably evil. In The Looking Glass Wars, I always got the impression that Redd was slightly bald. And old.

[General Doppel Ganger]

Out of those I'd have to say Helena Bonham Carter.

[dark_faerie_knight]

i have a feeling uma thurman would be awesome as redd. she did alot of great roles throughout her acting career. lol, i remember her playing ivy in batman and robin and that just gave me the idea. shes got this cold beauty areound her and she can be one heck of a bad guy. kill bill was great. =D plus that les mis. flare.

=] just a thought...

[Molly_Madigan]

I honestly don't like any of the above mentioned as Redd...

I'll get back to you on who I would choose though.

[are_you_seeing_redd]

I had thought about Michelle Pfiefer playing her, but Michelle is too old...

Honestly, I can't say who would play a good Redd--no one seems good enough for my favorite character XD

[Molly_Madigan]

I finally found the lady i think would make a good redd.. but I have to find her name better.

Its Miranda.. something.



Miranda Richardson.. I think she'd be good..

[Her Imperial Viciousness]

While she might be a little big for the role, I would not be against Angelina Jolie. Two words: "Girl Interrupted" :D

Whee, nutty!

[Molly_Madigan]

I still have yet to see Angelina Jolie in a movie.

But to me she doesn't seem to look right for the role. (to me..)

[Molly_Madigan]

Oh! Oh! I have pictures! Yay

they aren't the best but this is Miranda Richardson

http://web.ukonline.co.uk/miranda.jsrpages/scans/richardsonm/snowwhite/09.jpg
http://web.ukonline.co.uk/miranda.jsrpages/scans/richardsonm/snowwhite/04.jpg
That's from Snow White. (I haven't actually seen this movie.. >.<)

From Merlin
http://web.ukonline.co.uk/miranda.jsrpages/pics/2mrlm1.jpg
http://web.ukonline.co.uk/miranda.jsrpages/pics/2mrlm2.jpg
(She looked better as Mab.)

Sleepy Hollow
http://web.ukonline.co.uk/miranda.jsrpages/pics2/2mrlsh.jpg

And I know those are older movies, but she's still pretty.
She was also Madame Giry in the Phantom of the Opera.. That's a bit newer than the other ones if you want to search for pictures.

But yeah, that's who I think would make a good Redd.

[Loiterer]

Miranda Richardson would be good!

She does seem to play a lot of regal roles...

Like Queeny from Blackadder II!

[Molly_Madigan]

Miranda Richardson would be good!

She does seem to play a lot of regal roles...

Like Queeny from Blackadder II!

Yay! You know that too! -hug-

I need to watch more Black Adder..

[Loiterer]

Yay! You know that too! -hug-

I need to watch more Black Adder..

I'm British! Blackadder, Python, Bottom and all the rest are what I was raised on!

[Molly_Madigan]

Lol, Monty Python FTW..

but anyway, I do love Miranda and she would do very good I think.

[Loiterer]

Aye, Helena Bonham Carter would also be good. She can pull off childish villainess.

[Molly_Madigan]

I like her as an actress, but her face seems too small for me(to play redd). >.<
She'd play a good older Alyss...

[Loki]

so i guess we can say Helena could play Redd because of the childish villinas side of Redd. and Miranda Richardson can play more of the look of Redd and the ecentricities of her adult side. kind of hard to decide after such complelling arguments but i still want Helena, when i read the book, i only imagined her playing Redd.

[Her Imperial Viciousness]

Well, I believe Miranda has Queenly Experience:

http://www.mabjohn.5u.com/images/darkgoddess2.jpg

[Molly_Madigan]

^_^ Yes she has. I even have an Alice in Wonderland where she's the Queen of Hearts as well.

[Alyss*Fan_]

why does everyone keep on saying michelle phipere umm...NO.... she would kill it does someone agree please please tell me someone is sane along with me.

[Loiterer]

Nah, can't see Michelle Pfiefer. Not Redd enough...

[ArrisColwell]

While she might be a little big for the role, I would not be against Angelina Jolie. Two words: "Girl Interrupted" :D

Whee, nutty!


Nah, I like the way you think. That was a terrific movie.


I think it's hilarious that Angelica Houston was put on the list. Don't get me wrong I *ADORE* the woman. But I mean..............how many of you A.) Know who she is and B.) Can name a movie she was in?

Hehehehe she's just a bit old, is all I'm sayin' ;)

[Her Imperial Viciousness]

Nah, I like the way you think. That was a terrific movie.


I think it's hilarious that Angelica Houston was put on the list. Don't get me wrong I *ADORE* the woman. But I mean..............how many of you A.) Know who she is and B.) Can name a movie she was in?

Hehehehe she's just a bit old, is all I'm sayin' ;)

*raises hand*

"Addams Family" - Morticia.


That's what I knew before going to IMBD and confirming other things.

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Love Anjelica Huston :D She was amazing in Addams Family and in Ever After...guess I never thought of her being a Redd, but she'd be better than three-quarters of those people on the poll :D

[ArrisColwell]

Oh man, Ever After! She was funny as hell in that! Hehe :D

I'm proud of you two! LoL

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Oh man, Ever After! She was funny as hell in that! Hehe :D

I'm proud of you two! LoL

^_^ haha! Love Ever After!!! I just watched it the other day and enjoyed it! Hopefully she at leasts auditions for the part of Redd ^_^

[We'reAllMadAsHatters]

No...ok...Helena Bohnum Carter is NOT aloud to play redd...alright.
I don't care who says what...she would ruin the entire movie.

[are_you_seeing_redd]

No...ok...Helena Bohnum Carter is NOT aloud to play redd...alright.
I don't care who says what...she would ruin the entire movie.

Hopefully they get a no-namer who just graduated theatre school (or whatever they're called...my brain isn't functioning right tonight >.< )...it'll bring a fresh face to Hollywood (and we all need a fresh face) and hopefully she'll be good... =)

[ArrisColwell]

That would be lovely!!!!!!! Some of the best people are "nobodies"

[Molly_Madigan]

Oh man, Ever After! She was funny as hell in that! Hehe :D

I'm proud of you two! LoL

She was also in Daddy Day Care. If I'm getting the movies title right.
My friend L loves her for no apparent reason. -shrugs-

[Molly_Madigan]

No...ok...Helena Bohnum Carter is NOT aloud to play redd...alright.
I don't care who says what...she would ruin the entire movie.

I agree with her not playing Redd, but I don't believe she would ruin the movie. She'd just have to get cast as the right person.

[ArrisColwell]

I agree with her not playing Redd, but I don't believe she would ruin the movie. She'd just have to get cast as the right person.



Like a puddle?


HAH! Sorry. That was uncalled for.


But I don't like her. *giggles*

[Molly_Madigan]

Like a puddle?


HAH! Sorry. That was uncalled for.


But I don't like her. *giggles*

not a problem, I'm not too fond of her myself, that's why I'd cast her as Alyss for an example.

And it would be quite hard for someone to jump through Carter.. O.o Imagine whoever it was playing Hatter just jumping. There'd be too much blood and screaming. Too messy for my tastes. Lol

[ArrisColwell]

Well when I thought about "what role would I let her play, if I were calling the shots?"


My mind went all Family Guy on me, and she was just this nasty puddle on the ground that everyone was walking on, but she had eyes and was talking to all the other actors.


And Peter was the cat. HAHAHAHAHA


I watch too much TV. :|

[Loki]

helena can't play Alyss because Alyss'es character is twenty years old. I'm sticking to my guns ans saying Helena is Redd. Reading the book I could only imagine her as Redd.

[ArrisColwell]

And I'm just sayin.

She could be a puddle.


A dirty one.







Man I'm glad I'm not on an HP forum..................LOL

[Molly_Madigan]

Lol at the Carter puddle Family Guy thing.

^_^

[Miss Lilly]

Hi all :) Out of the actresses named i had to say Helena because she's experienced in the wierd and the wonderful however i think it would be nice for the cast to be fresh, unknown people, so that there are no pre-made opinions of the actresses or actors and we can concentrate on the characters themselves :)

[through_the_looking_glass]

Ok Haven't you seen Sweeney Todd or Harry Potter 5 Helena Boham Carter is Red! She looks right she's the right age and she's been in alot of weird movies she could totally do Redd perfectly

[Molly_Madigan]

I honestly don't think she's right for it. Have you ever watched Merlin? Or perhaps, if you'd like a movie with Johny Depp in it, Sleepy Hollow? There are much better actresses out there. I totally and utterly opposed the playing of Redd with an actress that has problem saying certain words. I've never imagined her with a lisp (HBC has one.. It annoys me every movie she's in!!) so I honestly think the best choice would not be her.

I'm still holding for Miranda Richardson~

[AlyssH]

You all keep saying "She's the right age," or "No, she'd be too old," and stuff like that about different actresses for the part of Redd. Now I'd like everyone to stop and think for a minute about how old Redd actually is. I have a few points I'd like you to keep in mind when picturing Redd's age:

1) She is older than Queen Genevieve. She was supposed to rule Wonderland, but then her mother removed her from succession and gave the throne to her younger sister, Genevieve.

2) Genevieve had to be about thirty when Redd staged her coup. Most people don't (purposefully) have children until they're in their twenties (unless it's different in Wonderland). Alyss was seven when her mother was killed, therefore Genevieve must have been close to--if not older than--thirty. This puts Redd at least a couple years older than that.

3) Alyss was gone for thirteen years before returning to Wonderland. If we conservatively put Redd at about thirty-five at the time of her coup, she would be forty-eight when Alyss returned, probably closer to fifty.

So do the math, people, before deciding that an actress isn't the right age to play Redd.

Just thought I'd point that out.

[MollyCole]

You all keep saying "She's the right age," or "No, she'd be too old," and stuff like that about different actresses for the part of Redd. Now I'd like everyone to stop and think for a minute about how old Redd actually is. I have a few points I'd like you to keep in mind when picturing Redd's age:

1) She is older than Queen Genevieve. She was supposed to rule Wonderland, but then her mother removed her from succession and gave the throne to her younger sister, Genevieve.

2) Genevieve had to be about thirty when Redd staged her coup. Most people don't (purposefully) have children until they're in their twenties (unless it's different in Wonderland). Alyss was seven when her mother was killed, therefore Genevieve must have been close to--if not older than--thirty. This puts Redd at least a couple years older than that.

3) Alyss was gone for thirteen years before returning to Wonderland. If we conservatively put Redd at about thirty-five at the time of her coup, she would be forty-eight when Alyss returned, probably closer to fifty.

So do the math, people, before deciding that an actress isn't the right age to play Redd.

Just thought I'd point that out.



THANK YOU!!!!! Finally someone who understands!!!! I totally agree with you! :cool:

[Her Imperial Viciousness]

THANK YOU!!!!! Finally someone who understands!!!! I totally agree with you! :cool:

I have a reserved agreement, only because FB himself says that Redd's age is her mid to late 30's when I asked him about it. So most of the above with a few years shaved back.

[General_Arnold]

I have my personal perfect person to play Her Imperial Viciousness: Femke Janessen. Particularly the way she looked in the third x-men movie.

[bellabong95]

Oh yeah!! She would be pretty good! Maybe, they might have to age hr just a tad though.

[General_Arnold]

Possibally, depending on who they have play Queen Genevive. I mean I'm personally hoping for Kate Beckinsale to play her, and if that works out, then they won't have to age her that much...

[bellabong95]

Yeah, I agree! Why do you want Kate Beckinsale to play Genevieve?

[General_Arnold]

For a multitude of reasons. First off she's a fantastic actress! Secondly, I've always invisioned Genevive as looking a bit like her. She's old enough, but still looks young and pure, as Genevive should. Finally, I think it would be interesting seeing as how she's played the part of Alice in "Alice through the Looking Glass" some years ago.

I also think that Femke Janssen and Kate Beckinsale would play well off eachother, though granted, Kate wouldn't be in it for long. However I wonder how difficult it would be (especially with today's technology), to have Kate also play the older Alyss. It's doubtful, but I think it could work.

[bellabong95]

yeah... it could, but I think it wuold be better if they casted two different actresses! You must REALLY like Kate Beckinsale!! =D

[General_Arnold]

Yeah, she's my favorite Actress. Not only is she gorgeous, but she's really really good! I agree though, it would probably be better to cast two different people.

[bellabong95]

yeah, what movies has she been in? I caN'T REMEMBE HER IN ANY AND i WANT TO SEE IF i THINK SHE WOULD BE GOOD FOR gENVEIVE. Oops, sorry I accidentally hit caps lock.

yeah, one person would just be cutting it too close!

[General_Arnold]

Kate Beckinsale has been in: Underworld, Underworld: Evolution, Click (w/ Adam Sandler), Alice Through the Looking Glass, Vacancy, Van Helsing, Pearl Harbor.

I think she's got the right personality and right attitude to play Genevive. Like I said I've always picture Genevive as looking slightly like her, plus her and Femke Janssen look just enough alike to be belived they were sisters, but yet different enough to account for Redd's evilness.

[Loiterer]

She wasn't in Evolution!

[General_Arnold]

She wasn't in Evolution!

Yes she was, she was in both Underworld and the sequel, Underworld Evolution. She played Selene in both of them.

[Loiterer]

Sorry. Misread! I've only seen Underworld, and IMO it wasn't great...

[We're_all_mad_here]

I don't know if these actress' have been mentioned yet but in all honesty I have to say that Meryl Streep as Redd and Nicole Kidman as Queen Genevieve would be fantastic. Both are well trained, extremely talented and would be believable as the characters. :rolleyes:

[are_you_seeing_redd]

I'm still holding for Miranda Richardson~

She's kinda good at Redd, ain't she? I think she's a bit...old?

Angelica Huston would be my all-time favorite, but she's just a bit too old for Redd...grr. Couldn't she be a bit younger?! I'll have to go searching around for who I think would be a good Redd....

[We're_all_mad_here]

Miranda has already played a version of the Queen of Hearts in the live action Hallmark Alice in Wonderland. Of course, it's a totally different concept, Redd and the Queen of Hearts, but I'm sure that someone else would do Redd a little more justice than her.

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Angelica Huston would be my all-time favorite, but she's just a bit too old for Redd...grr. Couldn't she be a bit younger?! I'll have to go searching around for who I think would be a good Redd....

Wow...so I'm completely quoting myself, but I finally thought of something. I got around to looking for Helena Bonum Carter on imdb.com, and now that I think about it, she would play a great Redd! I mean, she's about the right age and she's a great actress. Boom-bada-boom, she'd be a great choice!

[bellabong95]

Kate Beckinsale has been in: Underworld, Underworld: Evolution, Click (w/ Adam Sandler), Alice Through the Looking Glass, Vacancy, Van Helsing, Pearl Harbor.

I think she's got the right personality and right attitude to play Genevive. Like I said I've always picture Genevive as looking slightly like her, plus her and Femke Janssen look just enough alike to be belived they were sisters, but yet different enough to account for Redd's evilness.

yeah she woul;d be a good choice I think!! =D

[General_Arnold]

I think it would be the perfect match. I am hoping that's the way it works. Not sure on a Hatter though...

[bellabong95]

yeah! totally perfect!

hatter is a difficult one1 There are so many people that would be prety good for him! it's kinda hard to choose!

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Oh, Hatter would be an easy choice for me! I think Clive Owen would make a great Hatter!

[General_Arnold]

I would agree. Clive Owen would make a good Hatter, I was thinking either him or Ewan McGreggor. That would be good too.

As for Dodge, I'm thinking maybe Hayden Christiansen. An older Dodge of course. Not sure about the younger one. Just my idea.... :cool:

[bellabong95]

Yeah i ws thinking Clive Owen or Ewan McGreggor too!!! =D

I know a lot of people think Hayden would be good for Dodge! but I would DIE if he was Dodge!!! I don't know why but in the star wars films he bugged me soooo bad! There was just something up with his acting that made him seem... I don't know, just phony I guess?!

[General_Arnold]

I agree. Especially in Episode 2. I have to say though it got a lot better in episode 3, but episode 2 was not his finest moment!

[are_you_seeing_redd]

I know a lot of people think Hayden would be good for Dodge! but I would DIE if he was Dodge!!! I don't know why but in the star wars films he bugged me soooo bad! There was just something up with his acting that made him seem... I don't know, just phony I guess?!

Agreed! I don't like him, and I think he'd make a horrible choice for Dodge!!!!! BLAH! I'll just have to look around and see if there is anybody decent enough...but it's a definite NO for Hayden!

[AlyssH]

Oh, Hatter would be an easy choice for me! I think Clive Owen would make a great Hatter!

Yay! I have an ally in my campaign to make sure that Clive Owen plays Hatter! :D (I know you guys are all sick of hearing me beat this subject to death!)

Oh, and are_you_seeing_red, you must vote for him (if you haven't already) on the "Who should play Hatter" poll!

[bellabong95]

yeah! I'm SO glad you agree with me! He did get better in 3 I suppose, but he still wasn't good!!! hmmmm, I really don't know for Dodge!

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Oh, and are_you_seeing_red, you must vote for him (if you haven't already) on the "Who will play Hatter" poll!

There's a poll for that? I looked but I didn't find one...humph. I guess I must have been looking in the wrong spot :D haha...but most definitely!

[AlyssH]

Yeah, it's under General Discussion, but no one's voted on it for a while, so it's on the second page. Please vote!

[General_Arnold]

yeah! I'm SO glad you agree with me! He did get better in 3 I suppose, but he still wasn't good!!! hmmmm, I really don't know for Dodge!

I would agree, it's a hard one. My vote for Hatter (and I'll put this on the hatter pole) is Ewan McGreggor. I think he would work well.

[WILMA-weaver]

For a role like this, i believe it would be wise to cast an unknown.

[General_Arnold]

I was actually thinking of saving the "unknown lead" for Alyss herself actually. I think that having an unknown for Alyss supported by good, well known actors will make it all the more special!

[bellabong95]

AHHHH General Arnold you read my mind!!!! That is EXACTLY what I think too!! =D

I think that would be SO perfect as long as they got a talented actress!

[General_Arnold]

Thanks:D
Even if the actress has played a very small background role in another show, to give them their first lead in this would be good, but you are right, talent is a make or break for Alyss! It's almost as if the actress should have to pass through their own looking glass maze to get the part. ...WOW, I AM NOW A GEEK!

[are_you_seeing_redd]

Thanks:D
Even if the actress has played a very small background role in another show, to give them their first lead in this would be good, but you are right, talent is a make or break for Alyss! It's almost as if the actress should have to pass through their own looking glass maze to get the part. ...WOW, I AM NOW A GEEK!
No! That would be completely awesome, making us both geeks :D That would be super awesome!

[bellabong95]

I agree!!! lol I hope they take their time on casting Alyss!

YAY now we can all be geeks together!!! ;)

[General_Arnold]

YAY FOR GEEKDOM! So let's see that gives us Kingdoms, Queendoms and GEEDOMS! We rule....

Anyway. They need to take their time casting everyone. This could go really well, or really really badly depending on who they cast and how much effort they put into it.

[bellabong95]

lol YESSSS!!! =D

yeah seriously! If they cast someone who is totally cheesy or just really bad at acting that part then I will be TICKED!!! lol I really hope that this movie will make it because its just so......well... UTTERLY AMAZINGLY AWESOME!!! =D

Has anyone seen Something About Mary? the other movie FB did because I haven't and I want to know if he did a good job... if he did a good job with that one then he will probably do good on this one!

[AlyssH]

I've seen There's Something About Mary. It was an extremely successful film, but it's a very different genre from LGW, so it would be hard to compare.

[General_Arnold]

Honestly can't say as I've seen it, but I've heard good things about it, so there's hope.

[bellabong95]

ok! It was Cameron Diaz and Ben Stiller though right?! Their good actors! but both are very well known.... hmmm this brings me to the question of if he reads this forum yet again.... :confused:

[General_Arnold]

True, but as I said, and I think it was agreed, that well knowns for the adult parts would be ok, Alyss would be the unknown.

As I said about "Something about Mary" From what I've heard it's good, though I have not seen it myself. Plus we have one other thing going for us, the author of the book is writing the screen-play, which means more of the movie will end up in the book than normally does when the author has nothing to do with it. Again there's hope....

[bellabong95]

yeah! I've also heard it was good and there DEFINATELY is hope!! =D thats such a good point, I hate it when they cut the book up a lot and take out scenes... maybe this will actually be a movie that's better than the book?! It doesn't happen often, but then again neither does the writer being the screen-play as well....

[AlyssH]

Yeah, the other thing about Frank Beddor writing the screenplay is that if thing have to be changed for one reason or another, he'll at least make changes that are closer to the heart of the story. Because who would know better what a story is all about than its creator?

[Queen_Alyss_Anders]

I can see Angelica Houston, Indina Menzel and Michelle Phipher as Redd. All the others (whoever set up this poll) are either too young looking or to old looking. I am REALLY out of the loop because I had to google all these actors in order to vote.

[bellabong95]

Yeah, the other thing about Frank Beddor writing the screenplay is that if thing have to be changed for one reason or another, he'll at least make changes that are closer to the heart of the story. Because who would know better what a story is all about than its creator?

that is SO true! Have either of you met frank beddor? at school or a comicon or anything?!

[General_Arnold]

I haven't. I agree with Queen Alyss Anders, though. If changes had to be made for film time or something he'll know exactly what to change and how to do it. But there is still room for director interpertation, so my hope is that Mr. Beddor is planning on staying on hand to prevent that from happening. Also, I hope he has at least some hand in the casting. Who would know the characters better than him....

[AlyssH]

I haven't met Frank Beddor either. *tear* I really super want to, though! He never seems to come to my neck of the woods. :(

[Loiterer]

'Least you're closer. If he ever comes to England, I'll possibly be there... depends on work... (yes, that's right, kiddies, I have a job, it's rubbish but it pays the bills!)

And if not, I'll have to try fork out however much it is to go to America, get a hotel room booked, get a ticket for Comicon...

[AlyssH]

Ah, but he does go to England! You can check out the photos from his various book tours right here on the website. So you can't really whine, Loiterer.

By the way, I don't mean to pry, but what exactly is it you do for a job? Just...(okay, can't resist)...curiouser and curiouser.

[Queen_Alyss_Anders]

What do you agree with me on General Arnold? Cuz I'm not quite sure.:confused:

[Loiterer]

Ah, but he does go to England! You can check out the photos from his various book tours right here on the website. So you can't really whine, Loiterer.

By the way, I don't mean to pry, but what exactly is it you do for a job? Just...(okay, can't resist)...curiouser and curiouser.

Fine, if he does another promo tour anywhere near me, I shall make an effort to go along.

As for my job I have a part-time job stack shelves and slacking off in a local supermarket called Morrisons. And it's so odd some days, I've found myself writing a comedy series based in a similar place...

[AlyssH]

Well, you know what the teacher tells you when you're in elementary school (what is it for you? Primary school? something like that): "Write about what you know and care about."

I'm not quite so sure about the caring bit in your case, but the knowing certainly applies.

[General_Arnold]

What do you agree with me on General Arnold? Cuz I'm not quite sure.:confused:

You'd said that if changes had to be made to the script, it was better that he do them because he knows the story better than anyone. That's what I was agreeing with.

[Princess Maddy]

i have a feeling uma thurman would be awesome as redd. she did alot of great roles throughout her acting career. lol, i remember her playing ivy in batman and robin and that just gave me the idea. shes got this cold beauty areound her and she can be one heck of a bad guy. kill bill was great. =D plus that les mis. flare.

=] just a thought...
Uma would be a great choice! Ahhh man, Batman and Robin really sucked! LMAO!

[Loiterer]

Uma would be a great choice! Ahhh man, Batman and Robin really sucked! LMAO!


Don't you dare mention that waste of celluloid in my presence again! As soon as Burton left the Bat-franchise and gave it to Schumacher, it bombed! However, Schumacher did a good job with Falling Down...

Anyway, for Redd I think that Rachel Weisz would be good. It'd be interesting to see if she could pull off a petulant, bossy, bitchy redhead. Also it'd be nice to see her as a villain!

[The Tainted Truth]

Out of those I'd have to say Helena Bonham Carter.

I agree after her preformance in Sweeney Todd [Once again mispelled] she just seems like an amazing actress. [not that she wasen't before]

[Princess Maddy]

Don't you dare mention that waste of celluloid in my presence again! As soon as Burton left the Bat-franchise and gave it to Schumacher, it bombed! However, Schumacher did a good job with Falling Down...

Anyway, for Redd I think that Rachel Weisz would be good. It'd be interesting to see if she could pull off a petulant, bossy, bitchy redhead. Also it'd be nice to see her as a villain!
Oh don't worry, I probably won't!

[homburgmolly_fan]

I think Helena Bonham Carter is the best choice. In alot of the animated movies she's voiced, I never think "Oh, that is so obviously Helena Bonham Carter". I know those are only animated, but it goes to show how much she can change herself for a certain character.

http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb307/Bellatrixje/Helena%20Bonham%20Carter/SweeneyTodd.jpg

http://lh3.ggpht.com/fisherwy/R4eeQme9xMI/AAAAAAAAMuw/SEOVWv_HYYo/Helena+Bonham+Carter+at+the+premiere+of+Sweeney+To dd++in+London+picture%5B21%5D

Besides, doesn't she look a little "Redd-ish" to you?

[Princess Maddy]

I think Helena Bonham Carter is the best choice. In alot of the animated movies she's voiced, I never think "Oh, that is so obviously Helena Bonham Carter". I know those are only animated, but it goes to show how much she can change herself for a certain character.

http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb307/Bellatrixje/Helena%20Bonham%20Carter/SweeneyTodd.jpg

http://lh3.ggpht.com/fisherwy/R4eeQme9xMI/AAAAAAAAMuw/SEOVWv_HYYo/Helena+Bonham+Carter+at+the+premiere+of+Sweeney+To dd++in+London+picture%5B21%5D

Besides, doesn't she look a little "Redd-ish" to you?
Ok, never mind! Helena it is! lol! :D She does look reddish.

[homburgmolly_fan]

Doesn't she though? LOL

[Princess Maddy]

Doesn't she though? LOL
Totally! :D :D :D

[bellabong95]

Helena bonham carter is someone I REALLY can picture as REDD!! I think she'd be PERFECT!! =D

[Princess Maddy]

Helena bonham carter is someone I REALLY can picture as REDD!! I think she'd be PERFECT!! =D
So I guess we figured that out! :D